Showing posts with label New Deal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Deal. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Confusion about the New Deal

Steven Colbert interviews Jonathan Chait of the New Republic about the New Deal:

The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
The New Deal - Jonathan Chait
comedycentral.com
Colbert Report Full EpisodesPolitical HumorNASA Name Contest

People tend to talk about the "New Deal" as if it were one policy, when in reality it was a hodgepodge policies, regulations, and spending - some of which worked, some of which didn't. Many of the regulations did create serious market distortions, which impeded recovery, as Harold Cole and Lee Ohanian note:
"The most damaging policies were those at the heart of the recovery plan, including The National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA), which tossed aside the nation's antitrust acts and permitted industries to collusively raise prices provided that they shared their newfound monopoly rents with workers by substantially raising wages well above underlying productivity growth. The NIRA covered over 500 industries, ranging from autos and steel, to ladies hosiery and poultry production. Each industry created a code of "fair competition" which spelled out what producers could and could not do, and which were designed to eliminate "excessive competition" that FDR believed to be the source of the Depression.

These codes distorted the economy by artificially raising wages and prices, restricting output, and reducing productive capacity by placing quotas on industry investment in new plants and equipment. Following government approval of each industry code, industry prices and wages increased substantially, while prices and wages in sectors that weren't covered by the NIRA, such as agriculture, did not. We have calculated that manufacturing wages were as much as 25% above the level that would have prevailed without the New Deal. And while the artificially high wages created by the NIRA benefited the few that were fortunate to have a job in those industries, they significantly depressed production and employment, as the growth in wage costs far exceeded productivity growth."
Further, economist Robert Higgs provides evidence that the uncertainty created by the Roosevelt administration spooked businessmen, stifling investment.

Of course, that's not what the commentators in the clip are harping on. Their concern is the spending in the new stimulus plan; and on that, they have things mixed up. Both George Will and Sean Hannity are shown arguing that it was World War II, not the New Deal, that brought us out of the Depression. But how could a war bring the country out of the Depression? Through large-scale expansion of government spending! Bruce Bartlett explains:
"The [Great Depression] didn't really end until both monetary and fiscal policy became expansive with the onset of World War II. At that point, no one worried any more about budget deficits, and the Fed pegged interest rates to ensure that they stayed low, increasing the money supply as necessary to achieve this goal.

It was then and only then that the Great Depression truly ended. As a consequence, economists concluded that an expansive monetary and fiscal policy, which had been advocated by economist John Maynard Keynes throughout the 1930s, was the key to getting out of a depression."
So if you're arguing against the stimulus, you don't want to say that the War got us out of the Depression; if you do, you'll kind of undermine your entire argument.

Saturday, November 22, 2008

Tyler Cowen on lessons from the New Deal

We've been hearing a lot these days about the need for a new New Deal to save the economy. Tyler Cowen goes through some of the lessons of the old New Deal to show what did and didn't work:
"The good New Deal policies, like constructing a basic social safety net, made sense on their own terms and would have been desirable in the boom years of the 1920s as well. The bad policies made things worse. Today, that means we should restrict extraordinary measures to the financial sector as much as possible and resist the temptation to “do something” for its own sake."
There can be a real danger in just trying to do something. As Cowen points out, the old New Deal was a mixed bag of ad hoc policies, some very good and some very bad. We'd certainly be better off today without the legacy of agricultural subsidies.

It's also important to remember what really drove the recovery in the 1930s:
"A study of the 1930s by Christina D. Romer, a professor at the University of California, Berkeley (“What Ended the Great Depression?,” Journal of Economic History, 1992), confirmed that expansionary monetary policy was the key to the partial recovery of the 1930s. The worst years of the New Deal were 1937 and 1938, right after the Fed increased reserve requirements for banks, thereby curbing lending and moving the economy back to dangerous deflationary pressures."
Interestingly, Christina Romer was just picked to head Obama's Council of Economic Advisors. That's really good news.